The Economic GazetteAll articles

Economics & Policy

Did Canada's Fuel Tax Cuts Actually Reach the Pump?

When Canada scrapped its consumer carbon tax in 2025 and suspended its fuel excise tax in 2026, did drivers get the full savings, or did fuel retailers keep some? Weekly price data from 47 Canadian cities gives a surprisingly clear answer.

By Yuvraj Bharadia · · 5 min read


Line chart of weekly average gasoline prices, January to July 2025. Prices in Quebec, where nothing changed, stay between about 150 and 155 cents per litre. Prices in the rest of Canada fall from about 153 to about 132 cents per litre in the weeks after the 1 April 2025 carbon tax removal, then settle between roughly 134 and 140.
Image: Weekly average gasoline prices in Quebec and the rest of Canada around the 1 April 2025 carbon tax removal. Source: Natural Resources Canada; author’s calculations.

Two tax cuts, one question

On 1 April 2025, Canada set its federal fuel charge, the consumer carbon tax, to zero. British Columbia scrapped its own carbon tax on the same day. Together, these cuts took about 18.5 to 19.9 cents off every litre of gasoline (once sales tax is included) everywhere except Quebec. A year later, on 20 April 2026, Ottawa suspended the 10-cent federal excise tax on gasoline, a cut it described as temporary.

Governments cut fuel taxes to make life cheaper. But a tax cut only helps drivers if the price at the pump actually falls. If fuel retailers lower prices by less than the tax and keep the difference, the relief ends up in their margins rather than in consumers' pockets. So who really benefited?

“A cut announced as temporary was passed on as fully as the permanent one”

What economists mean by "pass-through"

Economists call the share of a tax change that shows up in the final price "pass-through". A pass-through of 1 (100 per cent) means a 10-cent tax cut lowers the pump price by exactly 10 cents. A pass-through of 0.5 means only 5 cents reaches consumers and the seller keeps the rest.

Which outcome occurs depends on how competitive a market is. Where many sellers compete and supply is plentiful, theory predicts close to full pass-through. Where sellers have market power, pass-through can be lower, or even above 1.

There is also a famous worry known as "rockets and feathers": prices shoot up like rockets when costs rise but drift down like feathers when costs fall. A study of European VAT changes found that prices responded about twice as much to tax increases as to tax cuts. If Canadian fuel retailers behaved like that, drivers would have paid the full carbon tax on the way up but recovered only part of it on the way down.

How I measured it

My analysis uses two public datasets. The first is monthly gasoline prices for 12 Canadian cities from Statistics Canada, covering 2019 to 2026. The second, and more powerful, is weekly prices for 47 cities from Natural Resources Canada, which splits every pump price into three parts: taxes, the wholesale price stations pay for fuel, and the retail margin stations keep. If stations pocketed part of a tax cut, it would show up directly as a wider retail margin.

The key comparison uses Quebec as a "control group". Quebec prices carbon through a separate cap-and-trade system that continued after April 2025, so its pump prices were unaffected by the cut. Comparing price changes in other provinces with Quebec over the same weeks strips out shocks that hit everyone at once, such as swings in world oil prices. Economists call this a difference-in-differences design.

Finding 1: the carbon tax cut reached drivers in full

In the first four weeks after 1 April 2025, pump prices in affected cities fell by 0.99 times the tax cut relative to Quebec: essentially 100 per cent pass-through, almost immediately. City by city, one-month pass-through ranged from about 85 per cent in Regina to slightly above 100 per cent in most of Ontario. That is a far more uniform result than earlier Canadian research found when the tax was first introduced in 2019.

There is one caveat. Over the following three to six months, retail margins in affected cities rose by about 2.3 cents per litre relative to Quebec, which suggests retailers may have gradually recovered around 13 per cent of the cut. A separate comparison with US prices points to a similar figure. This later effect is less certain than the immediate drop, but it is worth watching.

Finding 2: the temporary excise cut also passed through

The 2026 excise suspension is harder to study. It applied in every province, so there is no untouched comparison group, and it arrived during a sharp spike in oil prices. Using each city's own wholesale price to account for the oil shock, I estimate a pass-through of 1.13, with a margin of error of about 0.26, and retail margins did not widen. A cut announced as temporary was passed on as fully as the permanent one, much as Germany's 2022 fuel tax cut was for gasoline.

Finding 3: no clear "rockets and feathers"

Manitoba offers a natural experiment. It suspended its 14-cent provincial gas tax for all of 2024, then reinstated it at 12.5 cents in January 2025. The immediate price fall when the tax was suspended and the immediate rise when it returned were almost identical in size relative to the tax: 1.05 and 1.08 times the change. Across the wider data, there is no robust evidence that tax cuts pass through less than tax increases.

Why this matters

These results support the assumption the Bank of Canada made when it predicted that scrapping the carbon tax would lower inflation by about 0.7 percentage points for a year. The Bank assumed full pass-through, and the data largely bear that out.

They also matter for policy design. If fuel tax relief reaches consumers quickly and fully, it is an effective, if blunt, way to ease pump prices. The flip side is that when the excise tax returns in 2027, drivers should expect prices to rise by roughly the full amount.

Finally, the research carries a lesson about method. Small modelling choices, such as ignoring the sales tax charged on top of fuel taxes or comparing prices over windows that are too long, can make full pass-through look like 30 to 60 per cent. In tax research, getting the institutional details right matters as much as the statistics.

This article summarises the author's original working paper, "Do Fuel Tax Cuts Reach the Pump? Evidence from Canada's 2025 Carbon Charge Removal and 2026 Excise Suspension" (2026). All estimates are the author's own calculations from public Statistics Canada, Natural Resources Canada and US Energy Information Administration data.

References

Bank of Canada (2025). "How removing the consumer carbon tax affects inflation." Monetary Policy Report, April 2025. https://www.bankofcanada.ca/publications/mpr/mpr-2025-04-16/in-focus-1/

Benzarti, Y., Carloni, D., Harju, J. and Kosonen, T. (2020). "What Goes Up May Not Come Down: Asymmetric Incidence of Value-Added Taxes." Journal of Political Economy, 128(12), 4438–4474. https://www.journals.uchicago.edu/doi/abs/10.1086/710558

Dovern, J., Frank, J., Glas, A., Müller, L.S. and Perico Ortiz, D. (2023). "Estimating pass-through rates for the 2022 tax reduction on fuel prices in Germany." Energy Economics, 126, 106948. https://ideas.repec.org/a/eee/eneeco/v126y2023ics0140988323004462.html

Natural Resources Canada (2026). Weekly average retail prices for regular gasoline, by city. https://www2.nrcan.gc.ca/eneene/sources/pripri/prices_bycity_e.cfm

Statistics Canada (2026). Table 18-10-0001-01, Monthly average retail prices for gasoline and fuel oil, by geography. https://www150.statcan.gc.ca/t1/tbl1/en/tv.action?pid=1810000101