Society & Behaviour
The Ashoka Performativeness Index
By Sahasra Nangineni & Shloka Poddar · · 10 min read
Are you worried about the AQI? That’s cute. We think that you should be worried about the API: the Ashoka Performativeness Index. Considering that one of the most exciting parts of leaving school and coming to college is the freedom to dress as you please, there seems to be a suspiciously effective dress code enforced on the Ashoka campus. Down every corridor are a wave of people with slightly asymmetric postures shouldering tote bags, twisting the wires of earphones that run from their heads to their pockets. While no one can stop you from choosing to sacrifice the ability to listen to music and charge your phone or risk a straight spine for style, the counterintuitivity of these choices raises an interesting question: when we choose what to wear or carry, how much of that choice is driven by function, and how much by the social meaning we attach to it?
The underlying principles of it all come down to the simple fact that humans are hard to predict, irrespective of whether many economists would like to quantify their actions or ignore this fact. We often determine how we choose to present ourselves to the world by expressing ourselves through material goods. Practicality, unfortunately, isn’t always the priority.
In this context, performativeness refers to the extent to which our consumption choices are influenced by an awareness of how they will be perceived by others. It is not necessarily about pretending to be someone we are not, but about constructing and communicating an identity through the things we choose to consume. To investigate just how much of our consumption is performative, we surveyed 57 Ashokans in October 2026 about their use of tote bags and earphones, and what they believe these objects communicate. As it turns out, the economics of looking like you have read a book may be more complicated than we thought.
1. Serious Earpodemic
We noticed that between classes (sometimes in classes), in the dining hall, in Blue Tokai (obviously), or in the library, people often have wired earphones in their ears.

Nearly 88% of respondents said they would be less likely to approach someone wearing earphones in a library or study space. Interestingly, 78.7% of respondents who expressed a clear opinion associated earphones with listening to something or not wanting to be interrupted. In other words, a pair of earphones appears to communicate quite a bit more than the fact that someone owns a pair of earphones.
Why does this happen? We can’t directly observe whether someone wants to be approached, so we use the information available to us to make an educated guess. Earphones become a signal of unavailability, even though they may simply be playing music, a podcast or, in particularly concerning cases, absolutely nothing.
This is an example of signalling theory, that explains how individuals communicate information that would otherwise be difficult for others to observe. In the original model that tested this, employers would infer an employee’s productivity through educational qualifications and other observable traits to judge if they would be productive or not before hiring them (even though, as many Ashoka alumni can probably attest, possessing a degree is not the same as being productive).
The same logic applies to our earphones. The person wearing them knows whether or not they want to be disturbed, but the person considering approaching them doesn’t. Even if the signal isn’t deliberately being sent, we adjust our behaviour based on the visual observation. Ashoka isn’t special in this regard either; a survey conducted by Qualcomm aptX in the UK, found that approximately one in 10 Brits use headphones to stop people approaching them on their commute. A separate study reported by WSPA found that people wear headphones that aren’t connected to anything, just to dodge small talk.
This distinction between the person sending a signal and the person interpreting it is important. The meaning of an object is not determined entirely by the intentions of its owner; it also depends on the assumptions of the people observing it. A signal does not necessarily have to communicate the truth. It only has to influence what other people believe to be true.
Reports citing the research firm Circana say wired headphone sales rose in 2025 and jumped roughly 20% in early 2026, though the reports differ on the exact window. Some commentators add money to the mix: wired earphones reportedly average around $13, compared with roughly $99 for Bluetooth ones.
2. Tote-ally Everywhere

The tote bag offers a slightly different, but perhaps more obvious, example of signalling. While earphones communicate something about how we want others to interact with us, bags can communicate something about who we are. In our survey, 75.4% of respondents said that the bag someone carries influences their first impression of them to some extent. Furthermore, the most common association with the tote bag was personal style (47.3% of respondents), although close behind was nothing in particular. Interestingly, none selected practicality at all.
A tote bag is not evidence of someone's interest in literature, environmental consciousness or an obscure European film director. Yet, the object has acquired a meaning that extends beyond its practical use, and this value partly depends on whether other people recognise that meaning - which some do, and some don’t based on their own criteria of choosing these accessories.
This is closely related to the concept of conspicuous consumption, which argues that individuals consume goods not merely for their practical use, but also to display wealth and social status. The value of certain goods comes from their visibility: owning something is one thing, but having other people recognise that you own it is very much another. This is called Cultural Capital which was coined by the sociologist Pierre Bourdieu, meaning “taste that you can show off.”
Although the Ashoka tote bag may not communicate wealth, it can communicate taste (good or bad, who’s to say), interests and cultivate a specific persona. Consumption has a social function alongside its practical one. Buying the bag also means buying into the associated meaning and emotive baggage.
This brings us to a more complicated question: are these choices irrational? If a backpack is objectively more comfortable and a tote looks better, surely choosing the latter means sacrificing utility. Not quite.
3. What Are We Actually Buying?
The standard economic model of consumer choice assumes that individuals attempt to maximise utility subject to a budget constraint. Utility is essentially the satisfaction or benefit a consumer derives from a good. However, this does not mean that consumers always choose the most practical product. It means they choose the product they prefer, and the reasons behind that preference can be considerably more complicated than functionality, as demonstrated by the chart below.

This is where the distinction between cardinal and ordinal utility becomes relevant. Cardinal utility assumes that satisfaction can be measured numerically (eg, rating something on a scale of 1-10), while ordinal utility only requires that individuals can rank their preferences (eg. if I prefer Dhaba over Healthy Nook, and Healthy Nook over Hunger Cycle, I obviously prefer Dhaba over Hunger Cycle). In practice, we rarely know exactly how much satisfaction a tote bag gives us compared to a backpack. We simply know which one we would rather have. And, unfortunately for the backpack industry, that preference may have very little to do with how many books the bag can actually hold.
We can think of the utility derived from an accessory as having three components:
U = Uf + Ua + Us
where (Uf) represents functional utility, (Ua) aesthetic utility and (Us) social utility. The first concerns what an object does, the second how it looks, and the third how it influences the way its owner is perceived.
A backpack may offer greater functional utility because it is more comfortable and can carry approximately the entire contents of one's room. A tote bag, on the other hand, might offer greater aesthetic, social utility or any n criteria varying from person to person. If the combined satisfaction from these latter components outweighs the loss in functionality, choosing the tote is still perfectly rational within the consumer's own preferences. The problem is not that consumers are irrationally choosing aesthetics over functionality; it is that we tend to assume functionality is the only thing that should matter.
Our survey offers some evidence of this relationship. Among respondents who used tote bags, 88.5% said appearance influenced their choice of bag. Among non-users, the corresponding figure was 54.8%. Appearance, therefore, appears to be a considerably more common consideration among tote users. However, we did not find a statistically significant difference in whether respondents were willing to choose an item despite having a more practical alternative. We cannot conclude that tote users are necessarily sacrificing practicality for aesthetics, although they may be sacrificing their own shoulders.
The distinction matters because economic rationality is not about making the most practical choice; it is about making a choice that maximises one's own preferences. If we derive satisfaction from the way an object looks, or from the way other people perceive us when we use it, these are still components of our utility. In fact, if social recognition contributes to the satisfaction we derive from consumption, then other people's perceptions have effectively become part of our utility function.
4. The Bandwagon Effect and Brain Signalling: One Tote at a Time
There is, however, a problem with treating these preferences as entirely individual. If the social meaning attached to an object influences how much utility we derive from it, where does that meaning come from in the first place?
The answer may lie in the bandwagon effect that describes the tendency for individuals to increase their demand for a good because other people are consuming it. Rather than making consumption decisions in isolation, individuals take cues from the behaviour of those around them. The more popular an object becomes, the more desirable it can appear. This does not mean spotting a Longchamp in AC02 will instantly cause 20 more people to buy one - but it can be a subconscious influence. 21.1% of respondents admitted to having changed their choice of accessory based on what they saw others using. As more people carry tote bags, they become increasingly recognisable as part of a particular campus aesthetic. Preferences can be endogenous, which makes distinction between independently liking an object and liking it because other people like it becomes rather difficult to establish.
We constantly fill in a story about people from tiny clues. Our own survey says so. It showed that among students, 79% had read earphones as unavailable. This is supported by the WSPA report as well as the UK survey, both describing earphones as a cue for unavailability.
Part of the reason for these cues is speed. Psychologists Janine Willis and Alexander Todorov had found that people form impressions of faces in about a tenth of a second. This shows how the brain makes its guess before anyone even says a word, and a wire or tote feeds the brain with these signals. A wire talks about being busy, and a tote talks about being stylish. Yet neither has said a word.
The problem is that shortcuts often fail. The earphone wearer might be lonely and want someone to talk to. The tote carrier could just be carrying a tote because their backpack zip broke. And if the signal is wrong even some of the time, that’s a lot of conversations that never happened.
This also complicates the idea of performativeness. Are we performing because we understand society’s expectations, or to express some form of individuality in an external medium? There is no particularly neat answer, and the two are not mutually exclusive. We may not consciously choose an object to impress somebody else, but our preferences are still being shaped by the social environment in which we make that choice.
5. Are We All Performative?
The difficulty with measuring performativeness is that the same object can be chosen for entirely different reasons. One person might carry a tote because it was free at an event, another because they like the design (or at least pretend that they do, because that money’s gone now), and a third because they think it makes them look like someone who reads more than they actually do. The object alone cannot tell us which is true.
A proper API would then need to measure several things separately across a much larger sample: how much appearance weighs in choosing an object, how aware people are of social meanings attached to it, how much their preferences are influenced by those around them, and whether they accept the tradeoff between function and aesthetic or not. Our survey is a starting point rather than a definitive measurement of campus performativeness.
Yet, whether we intend to or not, the things we carry around are doing a little bit of talking on our behalf. Perhaps the distinction between choosing something because we like it and choosing it because of what it says about us is not quite as clear as we would like to believe. And perhaps there is some satisfaction in looking like someone who has their life together, even if the bag itself is doing very little to help. Whatever the case, the API continues to keep watch (though not literally, we promise).